Question

As you read the article "Geronimo: The Warrior," use this table to take notes that will help you analyze the writing Evaluate the thesis statement
of the essay, the evidence that supports the writer's claim, the structure of the essay, the strategies that the writer uses to convince readers about
the claim, and any logical fallacies in the essay. Finally, based on your analysis, make brief notes on your opinion about the essay based on
whether it gives a clear presentation of the writer's claim.
B IV * *, Fort Sizes - - -
E Z 3
.
Essay Analysis Notes from "Geronima. The Warrior
evidence
overall quality

Answer 1

Answer:

thesis statement Geronimo became a bitter warrior after his family was attacked by José Maria Carrasco.

evidence The writer gathered evidence from Geronimo’s autobiography, which includes facts and anecdotes from his life. For example, Geronimo burned his belongings, his children’s toys, and two tipis after the Mexican attack.

structure The essay reads well, but it lacks the traditional structure of essays. Some irrelevant discussion is included as well.

strategies The writer uses a cause-and-effect strategy and an appeal to emotions (pathos). He argues that the cause was the Mexican attack on the Apache camp, which resulted in the death of his mother, wife, and three children. The effect was Geronimo becoming a ruthless warrior.

The appeal to emotions (pathos) comes in the description of the attack on Geronimo’s family. Rielly also describes Geronimo standing alone in a river after the attacks as a way of showing his state of mind after losing his family.

fallacies Edward Rielly’s article about Geronimo doesn’t seem to have many obvious logical fallacies.

overall quality This is a good essay. It focuses on providing solid supporting evidence, and it demonstrates clear cause-and-effect relationships.

Explanation: